| MintonSherman Minton (D-IN) | 1935–1941 | 1949–1956 |
| BurtonHarold H. Burton (R-OH) | 1941–1945 | 1945–1958 |
| ByrnesJames F. Byrnes (D-SC) | 1931–1941 | 1941–1942 |
| BlackHugo L. Black (D-AL) | 1927–1937 | 1937–1971 |
| SutherlandGeorge Sutherland (R-UT) | 1905–1917 | 1922–1938 |
| WhiteEdward D. White (D-LA) | 1891–1894 | 1894–1921 (Chief Justice 1910–1921) |
| JacksonHowell E. Jackson (D-TN) | 1881–1886 | 1893–1895 |
| LamarLucius Q. C. Lamar (D-MS) | 1877–1885 | 1888–1893 |
| MatthewsStanley Mattews (R-OH) | 1877–1879 | 1881–1889 |
| ChaseSalmon P. Chase (FS, R-OH) | 1849–1855 | 1864–1873 Chief Justice |
| DavisDavid Davis (I-IL) | 1877–1883 | 1862–1877 |
| WoodburyLevi Woodbury (J, D-NH) | 1825–1831; 1841–1845 | 1845–1851 |
| McKinleyJohn McKinley (J, D-AL) | 1826–1831; 1837 | 1837–1852 |
| EllsworthOliver Ellsworth (Pro-Admin-CT) | 1789–1796 | 1796–1800 Chief Justice |
| PatersonWilliam Paterson (Pro-Admin-NJ) | 1789–1790 | 1793–1806 |
